Bestselling Historical Romance Author Elizabeth Thornton

The Pleasure Trap

The story behind the novel

I’m often asked if I ever suffer from burnout after having published twenty-four novels and two novellas in the last twenty years. My answer is “No, but . . .” It’s not burnout I worry about but producing the same old same old year in and year out. Writers need change (and so do readers) so that their stories stay dynamic and fresh.

Some writers introduce fantasy elements or science fiction or vampires into their novels. Others switch genres. In my latest historical novel, The Pleasure Trap, I introduced elements of the paranormal. It was a real challenge, though I’d done it once before (You Only Love Twice). But it’s the challenge that keeps a writer on her toes.

I’m also asked where I get my ideas for my books. There is no one answer except that each book is sparked from some very small incident and evolves from there. Start small—that’s my advice to beginning writers. Don’t become overwhelmed because you can’t see the big picture. Only a few writers have their complete books come to them in their dreams. I have never been that lucky. For me, writing is like learning to knit. You start out thinking you’re making a pen wiper, and lo and behold, it turns into a muffler!

That’s how The Pleasure Trap got its genesis, from a small incident, when my good friends Alison and Elmer Preece suggested that my husband and I might like to visit the quarry garden in Hamilton, Ontario. It had been a make-work project of the Depression era for men who were out of work. Needless to say, that quarry garden captured my imagination. When I got home to Winnipeg, I did a search on the internet and found other fascinating quarry gardens that had been created in various parts of the world.

“What if?” I thought, and I came up with a prologue—a woman who falls to her death from the top of a quarry twelve years before my story begins. The prologue raises questions that will be answered in the very last chapter of the book. That’s all I had—the prologue. I had no idea what would come next. There are two characters in the prologue, a mother and daughter, who are both psychics. Eve, the daughter, is fated to be my female protagonist, and waiting in the wings to make his entrance is my male protagonist, Ash Denison.

Ash was a given because he finishes off my three book Trap series. Readers have already met Ash in The Marriage Trap and The Bachelor Trap. They know that he is the darling of society. He has no driving ambitions, no need to prove himself and no unfulfilled dreams. He dedicates himself to enjoying the good life.

So where do I go from here?

Books are built around conflict and drama. Readers don’t want to read about characters who are so well adjusted that they never say a wrong word. When two characters meet, the sparks must begin to fly. That’s what grabs a reader’s attention—tension and conflict.

I think you see where this is leading. I needed a heroine who would be in conflict with the hero, someone who would shake him up a bit and make him question what he is doing with his life. Eve is the opposite of Ash. She is the one with goals and ambitions. Since I’m a writer and understand the ups and downs of a writer’s life, I decided that Eve should be a writer, too. In this era, Gothic writers were all the rage, so that is what Eve becomes, a writer of Gothic fiction.

Of course, it cuts both ways. Ash wants to convert Eve to his way of thinking. He wants to teach her about pleasure, in all its manifestations.

This friction between hero and heroine was to become a recurring theme in my novel. It’s based on the eternal question that comes to us all – Who am I and why am I here? In other words, what gives us our identity? What world view is right – Ash’s or Eve’s? They work on this conflict of character as the book progresses. This is what drives the romance.

I decided to add a twist here. Ash and Eve are poles apart in their thinking. How can I advance the romance? Eve has psychic abilities, remember, and much as she decries Ash’s way of life in her waking hours, in her dreams she becomes an entirely different woman. She finds Ash utterly irresistible.

At this point, I needed to give my characters backstory to explain their different points of view. It’s quite vague as yet, but slowly, as I write the story, more will become clear to me and their characters will become set. There’s more to Ash and Eve than meets the eye.

So far, I’ve been working mainly on the romance. The only part of the story that is on paper is the prologue. Everything else is in note form. Before I can begin on chapter one, I have to know how the story will end, more or less. What I need now is a special kind of energy that will drive my novel from beginning to end. In other words, I need a plot.

After much brainstorming, I came up with a symposium where all my Gothic writers get together to promote their books. One writer, however, Angelo, a sinister character who hides in the shadows, is publishing murder stories that are more truth than fiction and may have a link to the accidental death of Ash’s brother years before. Ash suspects that Eve may be Angelo.

The hunt for Angelo becomes Eve’s quest as well because she knows he is a murderer. With her fledgling psychic powers, she gets glimpses into his mind. She knows something else. She and Angelo are connected. This goes all the way back to the prologue.

Now I’m ready to begin writing my story, though, of course, only the essentials are in place. I still have to work on scenes between my hero and heroine that will tempt my readers to read to the end of the book.

I’m not finished yet. I still need a cast of characters as suspects and to help move the story along. They’re a given – the other Gothic writers and their associates from the symposium.

Odds and ends come to me as the story progresses. The Gothic writers are sequestered in a lovely estate close to the new Bedlam. I wanted to ignore Bedlam (now the Imperial War Museum in South London), an asylum for the insane, but a character kept jumping out at me, one of the inmates, a young girl called Nell and she wouldn’t leave me alone until I’d worked her into my story.

Something else worked it’s way into my story. I read in the papers about a wealthy English aristocrat who turned her estate in Cornwall into a safe haven for abused and abandoned horses and donkeys. As an animal lover and advocate, I was really touched by that news item. Hence, donkeys found their way into my plot, as did Sheba and Dexter, in memory of two fabulous black labs who have a special place in my heart.

One last thing. My stories always end with a twist, something unexpected that the reader didn’t see coming. I never know what that twist will be till I’m in the last act of my story. When I get to the twist, I have to go back to the beginning of my book and foreshadow it.

And that’s how The Pleasure Trap finally came to be written.

What’s next? More paranormal stories with a Scottish connection and, a first for me, set in the Victorian era. I know my readers love the Regency era of Jane Austen, but as a writer, to keep my writing fresh, I need to be challenged.

Some interesting links relating to The Pleasure Trap:

Quarry Gardens

Writers of Fiction—Gothic, Vampire circa 1816

Bedlam—The Royal Hospital of Mary of Bethlem

Donkeys & Donkey Refuges

Kennington, circa 1816

Vauxhall Pleasure Gardens

Reading Group Questions & Discussion Topics

 

Return to the top of the page

Elizabeth Thornton, July 2007: All Rights Reserved.